Season 2, Episode 35 (Show 87): Afraid to Ask: Hamilton and A Wealth Tax

August 24, 2022

Are we a Republic or a Democracy?  Yes, Akhil says on MSNBC – more on that here. Then, we go back to the 1700’s for the most important case of that century – with big implications for our century as well.  

Following Akhil’s MSNBC appearance on “Velshi,” we elaborate on how a Republic is a Democracy.  Does it matter – oh yes, and we explain why. Then we go back to the future – to the biggest Supreme Court case of the 18th century, with rock star Alexander Hamilton arguing, and the echoes resonate today.  So why haven’t you heard of this case?  Well, now you will, and follow a step-by-step explanation you won’t find anywhere else.

Show Notes:

Hylton v. United States (1796)

The biggest Supreme Court case of the 18th century, Hylton v. United States, sees Alexander Hamilton prevail with a unanimous Court.  Carriage taxes?  Yes, it matters.

Read and/or Download

Pollock v. Farmers' Loan And Trust Company (1895)

The 1895 Supreme Court rules on the constitutionality of income taxes in Pollock v. Farmers’ Loan And Trust Company, before Congress later has the last word.

Read and/or Download